Team

Cherish Asha Bolton, LSW
Resident therapist - *Currently accepting new clients*

Cherish (she/her) is a licensed social worker and works with adolescents and adults. She is prepared to address several needs, including college adjustment and career planning, life transitions, family separation, religious trauma, race/culture issues, immigration stress, and more. She is inclusive of all races, religions/cultures, and gender and sexual orientations. She is training in sex therapy and serves those in the ethical non-monogamy and kink communities in both individual and couples/family therapy, as well as helping those with experience in purity culture. Cherish is herself an intercountry and transracial adoptee, and she has experience professionally with and in advocacy for adolescents and adults who have either been in foster care or who were adopted. As a trauma-informed and polyvagal-informed therapist, Cherish is trained in Brainspotting and is working toward certification. Cherish’s passion is helping people explore their identity, examine relationships, and develop the best life for the person they want to become going forward. Cherish’s approach is relational and dynamic, justice-oriented, intersectional, and strengths-based. She collaborates with her clients as they walk on their journey of self-discovery and creating the change they wish to see in their lives.

Cherish sees clients 16+. Cherish currently accepts Medicaid (MHS, HIP, Ambetter, Hoosier Healthwise, MDwise, and Traditional), Aetna, Cigna, IU Health, and self-pay.

Fees: Initial session: $140, ongoing sessions: $125

cherish@atlastherapyindy.com Cell: 317-426-8746 (call or text)

Nancy Conway, LMHC

Therapist- **Currently accepting new clients, telehealth only**

Nancy (she/her) is a licensed mental health therapist. She has extensive experience working with teens. Nancy is prepared to address a variety of mental health concerns including depression, college adjustment, women's issues, infertility, parenting, anxiety, OCD, autism, career planning, grief and loss, adjustment, and childhood diagnoses. Nancy offers a warm respectful space for her clients to explore and identify the changes they wish to make in their lives.

Nancy sees clients who are 15+. Nancy is currently in network with: Anthem/BCBS, IU Health (Narrow and Premier plans), Aetna, & UHC/UBH/Optum. Fees: Initial session: $160, ongoing sessions: $140 

Nancy@atlastherapyindy.com Cell: 765-703-0141 (call or text)

Flora Crim, LMFT, RPT-S
Therapist - *Currently accepting new clients*

Flora (she/her) is a licensed Marriage and Family Therapist; licensed Clinical Addictions Counselor; and a Registered Play Therapist Supervisor. Flora has been working with children and their families for over 15 years in a variety of settings. Flora is trained in a variety of therapeutic needs such as anxiety, depression, ADHD, adoption, deaf culture, trauma and more.  Flora’s passion lies in working with children and their caregivers. By utilizing play therapy, she uses the child's language of play to help children to heal and thrive.  Flora also strives to form a positive working relationship with caregivers recognizing it is the hardest job they will ever have yet also they are the most influential when it comes to that child's life. Flora’s approach as a therapist involves supporting clients in discovering how to make this life worth living. Many individuals go through life just coasting day by day trying to get by minute by minute. While she cannot give you a magical solution to take care of all of life's problems, she can be there for you, listen to you and guide you towards living the best life you can have for you and your family.

Flora also offers clinical supervision. Clinical Supervision is provided to master's level clinicians pursuing licensure in Indiana (LMFT/LMHC) or certification in play therapy.

Flora sees clients ages 3+. Flora is in network with Anthem, Aetna, IU Health (Narrow and Premier plans), and UHC/UBH/Optum. Fees: Initial session: $160, ongoing sessions: $140 Supervision: $100

Flora@atlastherapyindy.com Cell: 765-667-9920 (call or text)

Alyse Tillis, LMHCA

Resident therapist- *Currently accepting new clients*

Alyse Tillis (she/her) is a licensed mental health counselor associate who works with children, adolescents, and adults. She has developed a diverse skill set that allows her to address several needs, including ADD/ADHD, Autism, LGBTQIA issues, mood disorders, cultural/ethnic issues, depressive disorders, and more. She is training in play therapy and is inclusive of all races, religions/cultures, and gender and sexual orientations. Her therapeutic approach is multi-faceted, incorporating various treatment modalities to ensure a comprehensive and personalized treatment plan for each client. These include Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), and Person-centered approaches, among others. Alyse firmly believes that no two individuals are the same, and thus, their therapy should reflect their unique experiences, needs, and goals. With a compassionate and empathetic nature, Alyse creates a safe and nurturing environment for her clients, fostering open communication and trust. She is committed to helping her clients navigate through their mental health challenges and empowering them to take control of their narratives.


Alyse sees clients9+. Alyse currently accepts Medicaid (MHS, HIP, Ambetter, Hoosier Healthwise, MDwise, and Traditional), Aetna, Cigna, IU Health, and self-pay.

Fees: Initial session: $140, ongoing sessions: $125

alyse@atlastherapyindy.com Office: 317-214-0863

See Sharayah's bookshelf here: Bookshelf 

Sharayah Tornquist, LMHC

Therapist/Owner- *Currently not accepting new clients*

Sharayah (she/her) is a Licensed Mental Health Therapist with over 14 years of experience working with children, adolescents, and adults. Sharayah is prepared to address a variety of mental health concerns including depression, anxiety, grief and loss, adjustment, and childhood diagnoses. Her counseling approach stems from a variety of theories including Cognitive-Behavioral, Motivational Interviewing, and Gestalt. She has also completed certification in sex therapy, which has given her experience with all types of sexual dysfunctions in adults and children. She provides a safe and trusting environment while helping clients work through difficult issues affecting their lives. 

Sharayah also offers clinical supervision. Clinical Supervision is provided to master's level clinicians pursuing licensure in Indiana (LMFT/LMHC) or certification in sex therapy.

Sharayah sees clients ages 12+, couples are only seen for sex therapy work. Sharayah is in network with: Anthem, Evernoth (Cigna), UHC/UBH/Optum, IU Health (Narrow and Premier plans), and Aetna. Fees: Initial session: $160, ongoing sessions: $140; Supervision: $50

Sharayah@atlastherapyindy.com Cell: 317-214-0863 (call or text)

Standard Notice: “Right to Receive a Good Faith Estimate of Expected Charges” Under the No Surprises Act


Beginning January 1, 2022:  If you’re uninsured or you pay for health care bills yourself ("self-pay"; you don’t have your claims submitted to your health insurance plan), providers and facilities must provide you with an estimate of expected charges before you receive an item or service.  


You have the right to receive a “Good Faith Estimate” explaining how much your medical care will cost 


Under this law, health and mental health care providers need to give clients who don’t have insurance or who are not using insurance an estimate of the bill for medical items and services. 



For questions or more information about your right to a Good Faith Estimate, visit www.cms.gov/nosurprises or call HHS at (800) 368-1019.